While the advertising world obsesses over AI’s potential to revolutionise creativity, I witnessed the most brilliant campaign of the year this past weekend – and it had nothing to do with machine learning, programmatic targeting, or predictive algorithms.

I was ankle-deep in mud at End of the Road Festival (which, by the way, was as outstanding as ever even despite the deluges), when a waste management truck trundled past, emblazoned with luxury brand advertising. There I was, filthy, tired, probably (definitely) smelling questionable, and suddenly confronted with pristine imagery of the very lifestyle I’d temporarily abandoned for three days of musical bliss in a muddy field.

It was perfect. It was contextual. It was human.

The advertising industry is currently drunk on AI promises. Every conference, every pitch, every strategy document now includes some variation of “AI-powered personalisation” or “machine learning optimisation.” Don’t get me wrong – these tools have their place. But in our rush to embrace the algorithmic future, are we forgetting the fundamental truth that great advertising is about understanding moments, not just metrics?

That rubbish truck campaign worked because someone – a human someone – understood festival psychology. They knew that by Sunday, we’d all be romanticising our normal lives. They understood that luxury feels most appealing when you’re living without it.

AI excels at pattern recognition across vast datasets. It can tell you that 18–34-year-olds who attend music festivals also engage with luxury content 67% more in the week following the event. But it takes human insight to realise that the optimal moment to reach them isn’t through their Instagram feed – it’s when they’re watching that rubbish truck haul away their weekend of excess.

The advertising industry’s AI obsession reminds me of every previous “revolution” we’ve lived through – programmatic, social, mobile, time shifted tv (Sky +/Q), video, influencer marketing. Each time, we declared the fundamentals obsolete, only to rediscover that great advertising remains great advertising, regardless of the delivery mechanism.

The real revolution isn’t in our tools; it’s in remembering that context creates meaning, that timing trumps targeting, and that understanding human nature will always matter more than optimising algorithms.

AI will undoubtedly make advertising more efficient, more measurable, more scalable. But will it make it more memorable? More moving? More muddy-festival-rubbish-truck brilliant?

I’m not convinced.

This isn’t a luddite manifesto. AI belongs in our arsenal, particularly for data analysis, creative versioning, and media optimisation. But let’s not confuse operational efficiency with creative effectiveness.

The brands that will win aren’t those with the most sophisticated AI stacks – they’re those that use technology to amplify human insights, not replace them. They’re the ones who understand that the best algorithm for understanding people is still empathy, seasoned with experience, and deployed at exactly the right moment.

Sometimes that moment is when you’re standing in a muddy field, watching a rubbish truck, dreaming of clean sheets.

And no machine saw that coming.

About Mostly Media

Welcome to Mostly Media, a proudly Independent, award winning, UK Top 20 Media Independent. Since '94 we have partnered with start up's, challengers and established brands to maximise the return on their media investment.